About The Song
“Why Should We Try Anymore” is one of the strongest examples of Hank Williams writing directly from relationship collapse without hiding behind complicated imagery. The song was written by Hank Williams and released in 1950 during his peak MGM period, when he was consistently issuing records that combined plain language with highly controlled structure. In historical context, this was the same era in which he was no longer just a regional star but a national country figure, and every new single had commercial weight on radio, jukeboxes, and touring circuits. That pressure helps explain the song’s economy: no wasted lines, no decorative storytelling, only the central emotional argument delivered with precision.
The release history follows the single-first model that defined much of late-1940s and early-1950s country music. Rather than being introduced through a modern album campaign, the track entered the market as a standalone MGM single and was later absorbed into compilation and legacy collections. That distinction is important for accurate writing, because many listeners today expect an “original album” narrative that did not exist in the same way at the time. Hank’s catalog was built track by track in real time, then reorganized later by labels into LP-era packages. “Why Should We Try Anymore” belongs to that original singles economy.
The song’s core idea is brutally practical: when trust and affection have deteriorated beyond repair, continuing the relationship becomes an empty ritual. What makes the lyric durable is its conversational logic. It does not dramatize with abstract symbolism; it sounds like one person stating an unavoidable conclusion to another. That tone matched Hank’s performance method perfectly. His phrasing often sits slightly behind the beat, with clear consonants and restrained vibrato, giving the impression of someone speaking hard truth rather than performing theatrical heartbreak. This is a key reason his breakup songs continue to feel modern despite their age.
A useful side story is how the song fits into Hank’s broader writing pattern at the time: he repeatedly converted common spoken phrases into title hooks that could be remembered after a single listen. “Why should we try anymore” is exactly that kind of hook—an everyday sentence carrying finality, regret, and fatigue at once. In commercial terms, this was excellent songwriting strategy for short-format country singles. It gave audiences immediate entry, helped DJs introduce the record quickly, and allowed live crowds to connect with the refrain without needing elaborate setup.
On Billboard performance, the song is documented as a significant country hit from Hank’s prime years, though his catalog includes multiple tracks with even larger long-term mainstream recognition. For publication-quality accuracy, chart specifics should always be matched to the exact Billboard country listing for the single and week in question, especially because historical databases and reissue notes can present formatting differences. The safe and truthful framing is that this record was part of his high-impact run of early-1950s hits and contributed to solidifying his reputation as country music’s most efficient writer of emotional stalemate and romantic finality.
For a deeper blog angle, position the song as a technical case study in minimalism. Hank uses a familiar domestic scenario, removes melodrama, and leaves listeners with a clean emotional equation: two people, no workable future, one unavoidable question. That approach influenced generations of country writers who learned that specificity is not always about extra detail; sometimes it is about choosing the exact sentence people say at the moment a relationship ends. “Why Should We Try Anymore” endures because it captures that sentence with unusual discipline, and because Hank delivers it as lived conversation rather than literary performance.
Video
Lyric
What’s the use to deny? We’ve been living a lie
That we should have admitted before
We were just victims of a half-hearted love
So why should we try any more?
The vows that we make are only to break
We drift like a wave from the shore
The kisses we steal we know are not real
So why should we try any more?
The dreams that we knew can never come true
They’re gone to return no more
False love like ours fades with the flowers
So why should we try any more?
Our story’s so old, again has been told
On the past, let’s close the door
And smile, don’t regret but live and forget
There’s no use to try any more